MCACS Program Committee
3:00PM Wednesday
22. September, 2004
The Conference Room “B”
The Italian Epicure
Novi, Michigan

  1. Call to Order:

    Daniel J. Reddy, MD, FACS, President-elect and Chair, called the meeting to Order at 3:29 PM. Doctor Reddy announced that Doctor Donald J. Scholten, MD, FACS, President is unable to attend this meeting.

    Present:

    Daniel J. Reddy, MD, FACS, President-elect & Chair
    Cheryl A. Wesen, MD, FACS, Immediate Past President
    Mark W. Puls, MD, FACS, Secretary
    Michael K. McLeod, MD, FACS, Treasurer
    Lee R. Britton, MD, FACS
    Gerard M. Doherty, MD, FACS
    John C. Eggenberger, MD, FACS, Webmaster
    Verne L. Hoshal, Jr. MD, FACS, Past President
    Kurt A. Kralovich, MD, FACS
    Vijay Mittal, MD, FACS
    J. H. Patton, Jr., MD, FACS
    Craig Reickert, MD, FACS
    Andrew W. Saxe, MD, FACS, Alt. Governor
    Allen Silbergleit, MD, Ph.D, FACS
    Yvan J. Silva, MD, FACS

    Also Present:

    Nervine Fanous, MD, Resident, Henry Ford Hosptial
    Edward D. Lanigan, MD, FACS
    Raouf A. Mikhail, MD, FACS, FRCS(C), Chair, MI Ca. Comm/ACS
    Farouck N. Obeid, MD, FACS, Past President & S.T.A.R. Rep.
    F. B. "Tom" Plasman, Chapter Administrator

    Absent:

    Donald J. Scholten, MD, FACS, President
    Keith N. Apelgren, MD, FACS
    Dennis A. Boysen, MD, FACS
    James Gruenberg, MD, FACS
    Jeffery R. Johnson, MD, FACS
    Larry R. Lloyd, MD, FACS
    James E. Reif, MD, FACS
    Edward J. Rutkowski, MD, FACS, Governor
    James G. Tyburski, MD, FACS
    Seth W. Wolk, MD, FACS
    Gerald Zelenock, MD, FACS

    2. Minutes: 18. September, 2002 Program Committee

    The minutes of the 3. March, 2004 Meeting of the Program Committee were reviewed. It was moved and seconded that the minutes be approved. This motion received unanimous approval.


    3. Report: Application for CME Credits through ACS

    Doctor Reddy initiated review and discussion of the ACS CME Procedure for Chapter Programs. Discussion ensued. It was determined to seek ACS CME approval for Category 1 CME Credits from the ACS.

    Doctor Wesen noted that Larry R. Lloyd, MD, FACS, Michigan Governor had submitted the Application for CME Approval for the 2003 & 2004 Annual Meetings and most certainly would be willing to be the Michigan Chapter Governor to submit the Application for the 2005 Annual Meeting. It was determined to confirm Doctor Lloyd’s willingness to do so. In the event that his practice schedule precludes him from taking on this responsibility, Doctor Britton volunteered to be the Application author. It was determined to complete all planning for the 19-20. May, 2005 Annual Meeting and Annual Resident Surgeons’ Competition so that the completed Application for CME Category 1 Credit Hours can be submitted to the American College of surgeons on or before 10. December, 2004.

    4. Review of ACS Guidelines for Collaboration of Industry and Surgical Organizations

    Doctor Reddy called upon Mr. Plasman to present regarding this document.

    Following a review, it was noted that the Exhibitors which participated in the 20-22. May, 2004 Annual Meeting will be mailed information pertaining to the 19-20, May, 2005 Annual Meeting and Annual Resident Surgeons’ Competition. There will be a second and third mailing before the end of December, 2004. Fall, 20034 is the time during which most Corporations prepare their exhibit event budgets for the coming year. The “Pharma Guidelines” will affect the Corporations Exhibiting Funds Application and Availability Process.

    5. Review of Resident Competition Abstract Submittal Form:

    Doctor Reddy initiated review of the Form and the Competition Poster.

    There was discussion regarding the possibility of Residents having electronic abstract submittal, and thereby initiate electronic abstract review and scoring by the Program Committee. Discussion ensued. Doctor Reichert volunteered to discuss this matter with John C. Eggenberger, MD, FACS, MCACS Website Manager and Mr. Plasman, to determine which computer program/processes were feasible and at what cost. They were requested to report at the next Program Committee Meeting regarding this possibility.

    The 2004 Abstract Submittal Form was determined to be used for the 2005 Competition with the appropriate date and location changes.

    The poster was reviewed. It again was determined to include information about the Michigan Committee on Trauma, 18-19, May, 2005 meeting.

    6. Review of Procedure:

    Abstract Submittal Deadline Date was discussed. It was noted that the AB site Exam will be conducted on 29. January; 2005. Discussion ensued. It was determined to schedule the Abstract Submittal Date to be Monday, 7. February, 2004.

    This initiated discussion pertaining to the meeting dates for the Program Committee and there being sufficient time for the Committee to peruse and score the Abstracts. Following Discussion it was determined that the Program Committee would meet at 6:00PM on Wednesday,2. March, 2005, preceding the 7:00 dinner meeting of the Council. The Chair requested that all members of the Program Committee, Young Surgeons Issues Committee and the Council be advised of this meeting date.

    The Committee requested that all Program Directors be advised of this schedule.

    There was then discussion pertaining to the date when the Publication and Mailing Date for the 2005 Program. It was determined that the Program would be mailed Friday, 11. March, 2005.

    7. Consideration of The 2005 Program:

    There were positive comments pertaining to the 2004 program, the increased attendance, the number of submitted Abstracts and membership participation. It was noted that the booking of the Michigan Committee on Trauma Program to be the day prior to the MCACS Annual Meeting, was a positive scheduling opportunity, facilitating surgeons attendance. Discussion ensued.

    Doctor Patton requested that when the Residents’ Paper presentations are scheduled, that the Trauma Papers be scheduled to occur on Thursday, 19. May, 2004. The Committee agreed with this request.

    There then followed a discussion pertaining to the opportunity for the Residents to be questioned about their Paper. Several alternatives for a questioning process were considered, as well as the possible positive and negative reactions to the opportunity to be questioned and that affect upon the submittal of Abstracts. Discussion ensued.

    It was moved and seconded that the ten minute time period scheduled for each Resident Presentation be timed so that there would be eight minutes for presentation and two minutes for questions, and that the questions may be posed only by members of the Judges Panel. This motion was passed by a vote of eleven to six. The Committee will consider the manner of implementing this process at the next Program Committee Meeting.

    The invitation of special invited guests was next discussed. It was determined that the doctor who is to present the MCOT “Mo” Henig Lecture also be scheduled to present during the MCACS 2005 Annual meeting. The Committee determined to extend an invitation to the doctor invited to present the “Mo” Henig Lecture.

    There was then discussion regarding the 2005 Annual Meeting Program emphasis on the diagnosis and treatment of cancer. Discussion ensued.

    Several possible speakers were identified, these being:

    Lisa Newman, MD, Director
    Breast Care Center
    University of Michigan
    3308 Cancer Center
    Ann Arbor, Michigan.

    Subject:

    George F. Vande Woude, Ph.D, Director
    Van Andel Research Institute
    Grand Rapids, Michigan


    Subject:

    Paul Shreve, MD
    Subject: P.E.T. Scanner, etc, etc,
    Someone from Detroit
    Subject: M.R.I. Scanner, etc. etc.
    Also scheduled to speak will be:
    Glenn Craig Davis, MD, Dean
    College of Human Medicine
    Michigan State University
    Subject:

    Anna M. Ledgerwood, MD, FACS
    First Vice-President
    American College of Surgeons
    Chicago, Illinois
    Subject:

    Edward R. Laws, MD, FACS, President
    American College of Surgeons
    Charlottesville, VA.
    Subject:
    8. Discussion: Local Arrangements:
    A Report from the Local Program Host, Donald J. Scholten, MD, FACS, President, was next considered. Discussion ensued pertaining to the composition of the MCOT Wednesday evening dinner-meeting membership. It was determined that MCOT would conduct a separate Wednesday evening diner-meeting, however, would be invited to participate in the Thursday evening special dinner event.

    It was determined to adopt the recommendations of the Report. Efforts will be made to schedule the following facilities:

    Wednesday, 18. May, 2005 The Council Meeting
    (There is no charge for the Council Meeting)

    Invited to attend:
    Council Members and Spouse
    Young Surgeons Issues Comm. Members and Spouse
    Frederick Meijer Garden
    Transportation via bus from Amway Grand Plaza
    Thursday, 19. May, 2005 An Annual Meeting Dining Experience
    (There will be a per person Charge)

    Invited to attend:
    All MCACS and MCOT Members And Spouse
    Gerald R. Ford Museum
    Attendees will walk from Amway Grand Plaza to the Museum
    Friday, 20. May, 2005 The Annual Banquet and Resident Surgeons’ Awards
    Invited to attend:
    All MCACS Members, Resident Surgeons and Spouse
    Amway Grand Plaza
    Pantland Ball Room
    A listing of Facilities, Activities and Events will be developed and provided with the Registration Packet for Spouses and Family Members.

    9. Identification and Selection of Resident Surgeons’ Competition Judges:

    There was a general discussion pertaining to the selection of Judges for the 20045 Competition. Nine names were suggested for consideration. There are to be five judges selected.

    Five surgeons were identified to be invited to serve as Members of the Judges panel, these being:

    Mark W. Puls, MD, FACS, Secretary
    Michigan Chapter American College of Surgeons
    Alpena Surgical Associates
    Alpena, Michigan
    Michael K. McLeod, MD,FACS, Treasurer
    Michigan Chapter American College of Surgeons
    Kalamazoo Center for Medical Study
    Kalamazoo, Michigan

    Larry Robson, MD, FACS
    2765 Woodcliff Circle, S.E.
    Grand Rapids, Michigan 49506

    Anna M. Ledgerwood, MD, FACS
    First Vice-President
    American College of Surgeons
    Wayne State University
    Detroit, Michigan

    Edward R. Laws, MD, FACS, President
    American College of Surgeons
    Charlottesville, VA.
    It was determined to request Verne L. Hoshal, Jr., MD, FACS, Past President to again serve as the Tabulator of the Judges Scores for the 2005 Annual Resident Surgeons’ Competition.

    This matter will be placed on the agenda of the 17. November, 2004 Program Committee Meeting Agenda, in the event one or more of the initially designated Judges practice schedule precludes participation.

    10. Identification of Future Annual Meeting Locations:

    The Program Committee acknowledged the location for the 2005 and 2006 Annual Meetings to be conducted at the Grand Traverse Resort, Acme (Traverse City) Michigan.

    11. Next Program Committee Meeting:

    The next meeting of the Program Committee will be conducted at 7:00 PM 17. November, 2004, at the Italian Epicure Restaurant, Novi, Michigan. An Agenda and Directions will be issued in late October.

    12. Adjournment:

    There being no further business to be brought before the Program Committee, the Meeting was adjourned at 11:12 AM.

    Respectfully Submitted,

    Mark. W. Puls, MD, FACS, Secretary

    Attest:

    Daniel J. Reddy, MD, FACS, President-elect
    and , Chair, Program Committee